Evaluation of Fungal Growth on Icynene Foam Insulation
Introduction and Materials & Methods
One building material product was evaluated to determine whether Stachybotrys and Penicillium fungal growth could be supported on the surface of these items. The building material sample consisted of a piece of foam insulation. A series of experiments were conducted with the insulation to mimic conditions that would promote “sick” building syndrome.
Insulation Sample. The bulk sample of insulation was cut into squares
5cm x 5cm. A total of three sections were examined in triplicate, each
section received Stachybotrys chartarum spores or Penicillium chrysogenum
spores. The samples were sterilized prior to testing by autoclaving. The
samples were placed into sterile glass jars. Each sample was inoculated
with 20ml sterilized water, to mimic a watering event. Fungal spores were
harvested with sterile phosphate-buffered saline solution (PBS) and
counted on a hemacytometer. The spore counts for both Stachybotrys and
Penicillium were adjusted to 1 x 105 spores/ml of solution. A total of 1ml
of spore solution was added onto the surface of each of the building
materials. Tryptic soy broth (TSB) was utilized as a food source for these
experiments, each of the 3 samples in a set received 0?, 250?, or 500? of
TSB. The samples were incubated in a disinfected chamber at 25?C, at a
relative humidity of 54%. Each sample was evaluated for fungal spore
viability at zero time and after a 15-day incubation period.
Each of the insulation sections received 1 x 105 sp/ml of either Stachybotrys chartarum spores or Penicillium chrysogenum spores. At zero time spores were harvested off of the surface of the insulation to determine the viability of the spores. The Stachybotrys spores inoculated onto the insulation samples that did not receive a food source had 1.5 x 102 sp/ml that were viable, after the 15-day incubation period 5.5 x 101 sp/ml were viable. Samples that received 250? of TSB had 1.5 x 102 sp/ml that were viable, and at the end of the 15-day incubation period there was 3.6 x 102 sp/ml, an increase in the number of viable spores. Similar to the samples with 250? of TSB the samples that were inoculated with 500? of TSB had an increase in the number of viable spores harvested from zero time at 2.2 x 102 sp/ml to 6.3 x 103 sp/ml.
Based on the results that were obtained from this study there are several conclusions that can be made. The results suggest that this insulation material cannot be utilized as a food source itself by fungi. The insulation was able to support both Stachybotrys and Penicillium growth after a wetting event with the addition of a food source. The insulation material did not affect fungal spore viability of both Stachybotrys and Penicillium fungal spores without a food source after a watering event.
CIA Since 1979
Contractor, Insulation, Air Barrier
(C) 2022 CIA